MURDER IS MURDER

Amongst all the people--lifers, LWOPs, short and long term sentenced individuals I've met in nearly 30 years of lifer advocacy, there are many moments, individuals and lessons that continue to be front of memory. And some of those are individuals I've come to know are continuing not only thier lives, but their rehabilitation under the shadow of the state that could come for them basically any day with the stated intent of killing them. The condemned.
At this point, the longest serving person under a death sentence in California has been imprisoned for 47 years, convicted in 1979 of two counts of kidnapping, murder and robbery. Henious crimes? Of course. And while I do not know this individual, I know several others from the former Death Row with similar crimes, 20 or more years ago.
And yet, those men (and all the individuals I know are men), the ones I know, are not the men who committed those crimes. It's what's called rehabilitation.
We have many students in our groups in various institutions, especially at CMF, who were labeled condemned. Most are thoughtful, changed individuals who, since release from the scourge of death row at San Quentin and disbursement to various prisons in the system, have begun to take groups, classes, therapy and the other life-changing and restorative offerings within CDCR. Prior to coming off death row they did not have the opportunity to program--and they are making astounding headway in changing their beliefs and lives, understanding their path to infamy and becoming the men they were meant to be. Many work in CMF's hospital and hospice facilities, determined to make the best and most pro-social life they can.
The Governor's recent action, commuting the sentences of everyone still under the threat of death in California to life without parole, has stirred the pot of, frankly uninformed public opinion again. Again, the commutation does NOT release anyone, nor, at this piont, does it offer the commutted a chance at parole via a parole hearing. Even if they do not have the opportunity to seek parole at some point (and I don't believe in never) they are grateful for the Governor's actions. And no, this does not minimize the impact, seriousness and harm of their crimes. And yes, vicitims have the absolute right, moral, legal, obvious understandable right to feel wronged yet again. Nothing will ever make their experience 'right.'
But here is where I stand---murder--the intentional killing of another human, is murder, no matter if it is carried out by an individual, a group or even the state. How do we, as supposedly civilized people, reconcile our willingness to commit what amounts to state-sanctioned murder, especially on those who were often young at the time of their criminal actions? As the old canard says, two wrongs don't make a right.
So I stand by what I have been saying, working on, even preaching for nearly 30 years--if we continue to keep people imprisoned because we're afraid of them, then we need to do a better job of rehabilitation, mental health and social safety. If we are keeping them incarcerated, regardless of their sentence, because we're still and will forevermore be angry and filled with hate for them, then that is not justice, it is vengeance.
And no government, including California's, can afford fiscally, morally or at the cost of their own soul, vengeance as public policy.




Comments